Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
New York Style
Caesar Salad
Minestrone Soup
Sticks Stones
About
Big Bill's New York Pizza
Welcome to Big Bill's New York Pizza, where authentic New York-style pizza meets the vibrant heart of Centennial, Colorado. Nestled at 8243 S Holly St, this beloved eatery has become a staple in the local community, renowned for its scrumptious offerings that encompass not only pizza but also delicious salads and delightful starters.
At Big Bill's, it’s all about choice and quality. Whether you prefer the classic Sicilian thick crust or the light and crispy Neapolitan thin crust, each slice of pizza promises to deliver on taste and tradition. The extensive menu features customizable options, allowing you to elevate your pizza with a variety of toppings such as pepperoni, sausage, and even veggies like broccoli and jalapeños. Gourmet lovers are sure to enjoy the Combo Pie alongside a dinner salad, a favorite among families seeking a satisfying meal.
One of the standout features of Big Bill's is its warm, welcoming atmosphere. With moderate noise and casual dress, it’s an ideal spot for families, groups, and pizza enthusiasts alike. The establishment boasts wheelchair accessibility, outdoor seating options, and even dog-friendly areas, ensuring everyone can join in on the pizza party. Plus, the availability of takeout and delivery makes it easy to enjoy their mouth-watering creations wherever you are.
Customer reviews speak volumes about the love for Big Bill's. Regulars like Mike G. rave about the quick turnaround time despite busy weekends, showcasing Big Bill's ability to manage a bustling restaurant efficiently. The service is consistently described as attentive, and the reasonable prices keep patrons coming back for more. Many also praise the garlic knots and other starters, highlighting the balance of flavors served with each dish.
If you’re searching for a casual lunch or dinner option that doesn’t compromise on flavor, Big Bill's New York Pizza is a must-visit. Their hearty pies paired with refreshing salads and a pint of beer create an inviting dining experience that embodies the essence of community dining. The restaurant even hosts fundraising events, such as the annual 9/11 fundraiser, showing their commitment to giving back.
Next time you're near Centennial, stop by Big Bill's and taste why it's celebrated as the best New York-style pizza in Colorado. With delicious food, great service, and a cozy atmosphere, you're bound to leave with a smile—and a full stomach!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Best pizza and salads in Denver! Perfect every time. Our family favorite is the Combo Pie & Dinner salad. ”
“ Great pizza and institution in the neighborhood. Bill is a hero in the the community always good service to go with the tasty food ”
“ After many years of coming to Big Bills, during lunch and also dinner hours, the best time to dine is either lunch or early dinner hours. If you are coming in during prime dinner hours, expect to wait. Also the parking can be a problem due to several very popular restaurants nearby sharing the parking lot. Looks like they have a nee menu but price seems to be still very reasonable. I have dined at the similar pizza restaurants and Big Bill still serves quality food at very reasonable price. . My go-to choice is the canzone, heros and of course pizzas. Service is always good, drinks are priced very reasonably and they keep the restaurant very clean. ”
“ Still the best NY pizza at the cheapest prices I've found in Colorado. My daughter and I came in on a Saturday night and were greeted with a 30-45 minute wait. They flip tables fast, and people ahead of us were seated quickly. We were called and seated right at the 30-min mark. The only downer of the meal were the garlic knots. While they came out quick, they appeared to be undercooked. Dense, and a little raw tasting, and yet, not overly hot. Good flavor, however. Maybe we try something else next time or just skip the app altogether. Slices stand up to any I've had before at other places. I got one pepperoni and one sausage, while my daughter had one cheese and one pepperoni and sausage. Great flavor, great grease to cheese ratio, and great foldability. What more could you want? Service may have seemed a bit slower than usual, but we were still in and out in just over 30 mins after being seated, and they were busy, so the waitstaff was busting their butts throughout. They were as attentive as they could've been. I always look forward to coming here. $28 before tip. How could anything be wrong with that?!? ”
“ NY style pie. Always good and cooked Well. They do a 9/11 fundraiser that is cool for helping the Susan b komen foundation. Take the family and have a pitcher of beer and a monster of a pizza!! Not fancy, just good! ”
“ Great atmosphere ... a story in pictures of Bill Finke's life, loves, and passions. A true home owned hole in the wall treasure worth the trip form the "big city" We didn't have to wait to be seated and got our food in a flash. Great place to meet up with old friends or for family supper. Some people really like the crust, but that was the only thing I wasn't in love with. They offer more than just pizza. Do yourself a favor and come in for a good meal in a true treasure; a little piece of Manhattan in the mountains. ”
“ Best NY style pizza in the Southern burbs. Very family friendly and a great place to visit family and friends. You can catch the man himself, Big Bill, there on a regular basis. He always offers a friendly wave and smile. ”
